Unit 11
The role of
error
Are mistakes good or bad?
Let me say something obvious first: mistakes
are bad. If one had a choice between saying a sentence correctly and
saying it with a mistake, nobody in their right mind would choose saying it
with a mistake and no teacher would recommend that. However there are some
reasons that teachers sometimes say that mistakes shouldn’t be avoided is that
they believe one of two things (or both):
- Those mistakes are an inseparable part of the learning process; therefore, the only way to avoid language mistakes would be to avoid speaking and writing in a foreign language, and that would be bad. (the “Mistakes are inevitable” group)
- That making mistakes, and having them corrected, is a good way to learn a language. (The “Mistakes are good” group.)
In
addition, making mistakes plays a significant part in language because it
allows learners to experiment with language and measure their strengths and
weakness in communicating.
On the other hand, teachers need
to know that mistakes are divided into errors and slips. To have a clear idea
of what refer each of them let’s gives a definition; error occurs when a
learner uses language unconsciously in order to understand and learn it but
they cannot correct errors themselves because they do not understand what is
wrong. Meanwhile, slips occur as result of tiredness, worry or everything can
disturb students’ concentration which makes them to commit slips it could be
when they are speaking or writhing.
Another important point why
learners make errors is the influence of learner’s first language (mother
tongue L1) on the second language L2 this is called interference or transfer.
In this part teachers should be aware that learners sometimes use the second
language in the same way that they use their mother tongue it includes lexis or
grammatical structures.
As a final relevant aspect from this unit and it is fossilation of errors may be the result of lack exposure to the L2, the result of a learner’s conscious or unconscious lack of motivation to improve their accuracy.
In conclusion, making mistakes is a good way to learn a language since it can helps learners to improve or realize what they are doing well or wrong with language but of course teachers take a significant role in this due to they should correct those mistakes in a positive way.
Here you have an interesting video about the role of error
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cipFuDxiF2Y
This is a good power presentation about this topic:
http://es.slideshare.net/MelissaFerrer/learner-errors-and-error-analysisppt-rev
Great job Leti!!
ReplyDeleteYou have a great understanding abou this topic. I Agree that teachers have to take a significant role incorrecting errors since from them not only learns the learner, but also the teacher to find out new strategies. I have checked your links and they are very useful for me..
I liked it alot !
ReplyDeleteI found the most important characteristic about error. as you say making mistakes is a significant part in language because it allows learners to experiment with language and measure their strengths and weakness in communicating. Perfect idea !
Excellent reflection Lety! I like the way you catch my attention in your first lines of the analysis!!! Definetely I agree with you that we can learn from our mistakes!
ReplyDeleteBy the way, after have watched the video I have to admit it was very useful!
CONGRATS!
Excellent information Leti! Mainly because you point out that mistakes are an inseparable part of the learning process and that having them corrected is a good way to learn a language.Good points to reflect on! :)
ReplyDelete